10. Wrexham FC
- creation date: 1864
- country: Wales
9. Royal Engineers Association FC
- creation date: 1863
- country: Great Britain
8. Civil Service FC
- creation date: 1863
- country: Great Britain
7. Stoke City FC
- creation date: 1863
- country: Great Britain
6. Notts County
- creation date: 1862
- country: Great Britain
5. Cray Wanderers FC
- creation date: 1860
- country: Great Britain
4. Hallam FC
- creation date: September 4, 1860
- country: Great Britain
3. Lima CFC
- creation date: 1859
- country: Peru
2. Cambridge University AFC
- creation date: 1857
- country: Great Britain
1. Sheffield FC
- creation date: October 24, 1857
- country: Great Britain